
The author and father of the men's movement, Robert Bly described shadow as a bag we drag around with us. He said we spend the first half of our lives putting things in the bag and the second half taking them back out. So how does shadow get created? Where does it come from?
The simple answer is we live on a planet where polarity is inherent. Nothing one-sided can exist here. Shadow is the compliment to persona, the face we show the world. We need a place in our psyche to hold the primitive and all else that exists outside the bounds of what is acceptable. What's acceptable becomes part of our conscious persona. The unacceptable is disowned into shadow.
So who decides what is acceptable and unacceptable? Our shadows are multi-layered. Shadow contains both personal and transpersonal aspects. Personal pieces of shadow generally come from firsthand experience. When we express a characteristic or part of ourselves that results in a painful experience, that characteristic often gets disowned into shadow.
Transpersonal shadow is largely comprised of second hand experience. The transpersonal relates to shared experience that is larger than a single human being, like the experience of a group. In this context the group can be a family, culture, society, city, corporation, economic class or even the entire human race.
Transpersonal shadow can be thought of as inherited shadow. Rather than rejecting a characteristic based on direct personal experience, we disown it based on the value system of a group we are part of. The group decides that characteristic or form of expression is unacceptable. We take that on because we are part of the group.
Inherited shadow can be challenging to even get a look at. There isn’t usually a personal experience we can point to as the place where we decided that characteristic was unacceptable. Often the decision wasn’t one we made consciously. Inherited shadow is embedded in the framework of how we live; in the places where we just do what we do because that’s the way it’s done. Most of the time these pieces of inherited shadow are so ingrained it doesn’t even occur to us to question them.
We begin creating and taking on shadow in childhood. Children naturally adopt the beliefs and characteristics that are rewarded. The reward can be praise, love, acceptance or a sense of belonging. The source of the reward can be a parent, teacher, religious authority, peer group or society in general.
As children, aligning ourselves with what is acceptable to our group or tribe is a natural survival mechanism. We know we need the group to survive. If we don’t adopt what the group deems acceptable, we risk being ostracized which threatens our survival. Children don’t have the ability to reason with their survival instinct, nor are they able to examine what the group deems acceptable and decide if it really fits for them. If as adults we continue to leave what’s on the “unacceptable” list unexamined, our childhood survival mechanism becomes a liability.
When we continue to act on beliefs about what is and is not acceptable that don’t truly fit for us, we limit our ability to be who we are. Feeling like you are doing something out of obligation is a clue to the places where you’re acting on a belief that’s not really yours.
Transpersonal shadow also includes what Carl Jung called archetypal shadow and projected shadow. An archetype can be thought of as an inherited predisposition to respond to the world in certain ways. Often archetypes are represented as a being, like a god, goddess or mythological figure, which embodies that predisposition. Archetypes are mythical structures that make up the primordial inheritance of the human race. Mother, father and child are all archetypes. The mother-child bond is an archetypal relationship. We all carry pieces of archetypal shadow.
Shadow projection is the process where we project our shadow(s) onto something external so we see that shadow piece as belonging to someone or something else. When we project shadow onto someone or something else it doesn’t mean that characteristic isn’t there. However our filters, created by our desire to reject that shadow aspect in us, intensifies our perception of it externally.
Projecting shadow allows us to deny it in ourselves in order to maintain our persona or self-image. Shadow projection can be an individual or collective process. When a nation or group makes another country or group the “bad guy”, that’s shadow projection. Scapegoating and hero worship are also forms of shadow projection.
In hero worship we take what is best in us and project it onto someone else. This is one of the ways we disown our strengths. In scapegoating a single person becomes the carrier of the collective shadow of a family or other group.
Shadow, as the container for all those disowned and unacceptable parts of self, is also the seat of individuation. By examining what’s in the unacceptable pile and deciding what really fits for us, we become unique individuals with something to contribute to the collective rather than shrinking ourselves into compulsive conformity.
Meeting the shadow requires the humility to let go of persona. We have to be willing to let go of who we imagine ourselves to be and meet who we really are before we can consciously create ourselves as who we want to be.
P.S. Apologies for formating glitches, etc. I'm using a new blogger app and haven't quite got it figured out yet.